Reviews For Seemed like a good idea at the time

Name: nott theodore (Signed) · Date: 03 Dec 2017 11:54 AM · For: Seemed like a good idea at the time

I don't think I've actually ever written Hagrid - he's one of those characters I find even more intimidating than the Golden Trio, but I loved the way that you captured his character here.  This was such a cute story to read, and really felt like it could be a moment taken from the books, I could picture it so clearly.


I loved seeing Albus being friends with Hagrid, the same way that his dad had been.  After everything Hagrid and Harry went through together, it's so sweet to see that friendship enduring in the next generation.  Albus's genuine interest in all of Hagrid's magical creatures must be so exciting for him, too - since we know that Hagrid doesn't listen to people who try and discourage him from putting dangerous creatures into the forest.  I think I'd probably take Scorpius's more reserved view on this one, though!


Hearing Hagrid talk so proudly about all the different creatures that he's introduced to the forest in his time as gamekeeper there is kind of adorable - he really hasn't changed at all, and his fascination for those creatures is still as strong as ever - but I did wonder what most biologists and conservationists would think of him just experimenting with the natural habitat :P


The ending made me laugh - poor Neville, losing his precious plants, and then Hagrid standing there and looking sheepish and embarrassed.  Will the man ever learn? :P


Sian :)

Name: Dojh167 (Signed) · Date: 25 Sep 2017 05:16 PM · For: Seemed like a good idea at the time

Omg this is so adorably cute! We see a lot of Hagrid being up to these kinds of antics in the books, but there is something incredibly charming about him in next generation, being so preciously unchanged. And very in character!

Hagrid never learns, and while that may be frustrating for some, it definitely makes me feel affectionately sentimental about him here.

I also think it’s so precious how interested Albus is in Hagrid’s creatures. That must mean a lot to him, because of his close relationship with Harry. But this is even better, because while Harry & co liked Hagrid, they merely tolerated his creatures. And lol, Scorpius’ attitude is such a callback to that!

Oh nooo don’t upset Professor Longbottom! =( I generally imagine him as a pretty chill professor, so seeing him worked up makes me want to protect him and his plants.

Everyone here is so perfectly in character, and I adore it! Even though this story is short and the individual characters don’t get a lot of page time, you did a great job of making them all feel very real. II usually find Hagrid intimidating to capture well, but I think you did an excellent job.

Well done!


Name: AlmaVK (Anonymous) · Date: 22 Aug 2017 07:17 AM · For: Seemed like a good idea at the time

Hi :) thank you for entering my Fantastic Beast Challenge! The Forums still seem to be down with the new site, so I thought I'd come here directly with the results. I had a total of seven very good entries, and the choice was hard.

1st prize: Fantastic good-night stories by Vilja
2nd prize: Serenity in Chaos by nott theodore
3rd prize: Harry Potter and Druidic Magic (Chapter 3 The Phoenix's Song) by StarFeather
Footesteps in the Forest by Dojh167
Seemed like a good idea at the time by melian
Forest by Rhaenyra
Tengu and a Daughter of Ninja (chapter 12) by StarFeather

Here is the graphic prize I made for you:
Reviews will be coming.

Submit a Review